I loved the first two books of the Lymond Chronicles, but when I began to read this book I couldn’t help thinking that those books were laying foundations and that this book would be where she really hit her stride.
It was wonderful to be back in Scotland with familiar characters from the first book who I had rather missed in the second. The opening sequence moved from Will Scott’s wedding to a skirmish with English border raiders and then back to the wedding party again. It and it was vibrant, it was colourful and it was a joy to read.
That set the scene perfectly.
In the first part of the book, Lymond was drawn into the cause of the Knights of Malta, as they struggled to defend their island home from the Turks. There was intrigue, because it was clear that there were more than the stated reasons the invitation extended to Lymond, and for his accepting that invitation. This early part of the story set in Malta and Tripoli, evoked those places wonderfully well. It was perfectly executed, it was immaculately written; there were some wonderful moments, there were some significant plot developments; and yet it was only setting the stage for events that would unfold back in Scotland.
Lymond was charged with creating a new military force for Scotland, its objective to break the cycle of clan warfare so that all of Scotland’s forces could be set against the English. Among the company is a group of refugee Knights of Malta, led by Sir Graham Malett, known as Gabriel, who is set on creating a religious force and making Lymond part of that force.
That’s as much as I can say about specifics of the plot; because there is such clever and effective sleight of hand, because my understanding of events shifted, and because if you have read this book you will know and if you have you should read and you shouldn’t know too much before you do.
The depth and the complexity of the characterisation is extraordinary; and a cast populated by fictional characters and historical figures lived and breathed. I have come to love many of them – Janet Beaton and Kate Somerville are particular favourites – and the death of one early in the story made me realise how very real this world and the people who moved through it have become to me.
There would be other deaths and some of them broke my heart. Most were dictated by the real history that is missed so effectively with fiction, and others I understood served the unfolding plot.
I reacted more emotionally to this book than others; and fortunately there were scenes to inspire laughter, anger and joy as well as grief.
Two new characters – a man and a woman – became central to the story. They were both quite unlike anyone else in the story, they were psychologically complicated and interesting, and they brought much colour and drama.
The success or failure of this book though, rested firmly on the shoulders of its central character. I am still drawn right in with his charisma, his manifold talents, and the evolution of his character and his story.
There were times when he seemed to have matured, but there were times when he seemed childishly, foolishly reckless. I would come to understand his reasons, that there were times when he had to position himself and play a part, but there was something there that came from character rather than pure necessity.
Certain things within the Crawford family that I had observed before were emphasised in this book, and I am very curious to find out more.
There were not as many set pieces as I expected in this book, but I didn’t miss them because there was so much that was rooted in character and history, and because I saw that much of what had happened before was building the story arc that would grow through this book.
I loved one scene that I haven’t seen mentioned much; an extended scene that had echoes of something the happened at the very beginning of the first book.
The finale was a tour de force, an extended set piece rich with colour, drama and emotion that set things up perfectly for the next book and the books to come after that.
I love that the thee books in this series have been distinctive but they have also been worked together to reveal different aspects of a character and to move his story forward.
I know that I will come back to them again and see things that I missed reading them for the first time, but now I have to get back to ‘Pawn in Frankincense – the fourth book – and find out what happens next.
9 thoughts on “The Disorderly Knights by Dorothy Dunnett (1966)”
Oh, Jane, you do make me want to pull this off the shelf! Kate and Philippa Somerville are two of my favorite characters ever. I did miss Gideon in this book.
The Penguin editions of the Chronicles are so beautiful. I do covet them, but I can’t justify a third set.
Pawn is not my favorite book in the series, so I’m interested to see what you think.
I love Kate but I haven’t warmed to her daughter her daughter, though I have a feeling the next book could change that, and I would have loved to see more of the whole Somerville family. I’m loving the beginning of Pawn, but I’m not far in and there is clearly a great deal to come.
You have made me want to read these again. I absolutely loved them – and fell in love with Lymond!
I wish I had discovered them sooner – I can imagine re-reading already.
Wonderful review, Jane! I love this book and reading your thoughts on it has brought back all the excitement and emotion I felt on reading it for the first time. Kate Somerville is a favourite of mine too, and when I read Pawn in Frankincense I came to love Philippa as well. I’ll look forward to hearing what you think of the other three books in the series. 🙂
Thank you, Helen! I’ve read the first few chapters of Pawn in Frankincense and I’m loving it, and I suspect I will work through the second half of the series much more quickly that the first.
I tried listening to the first one of these as an audiobook but didn’t get on with it at all. Perhaps I should try the print version.
I’m loving these books, but they aren’t for everybody, But do try print, because it is so easy to miss things on audio with this kind of book,
I think I probably commented on your previous posts about this series that I really must give them a go. Reading your latest post has firmed my resolved and I have ordered A Game of Kings from the library!
Comments are closed.