May I consider this fourth of the six books that make up Dorothy Dunnett’s Lymond Chronicles to be the beginning of the second of two acts?
I ask because the last book finished on a cliffhanger, and because I see parallels between this book and the very first book in the sequence.
They are both stories of quests, but his time the field of play is much wider and the stakes are much, much higher.
The narrative moves across Europe and North Africa; beginning with a remarkable scene in Switzerland where much is not as it seems, and then on to France, Algiers, Djerba, and finally the grand and great city Constantinople, where scenes played out that left me emotionally drained,utterly lost for words and desperate to know what would happen next.
The journey through this series of book is for the faint-hearted; but for those prepared to commit time, heart and intellect, they are richly, richly rewarding.
The quest in the first book was to find justice and the right place in the world; while the quest in this book is to find an infant, hidden away far from the place he should know as home, and in the power of a ruthless, devious and very clever enemy.
I’m trying not to say too much for anyone further back in the series or contemplating reading in the future, but I really can’t write about this book without referring to particular names and situations.
The ostensible reason for Lymond’s journey is to deliver a gift from the King of France to the Sultan in Constntinople; but the deeper reason is to rescue the child – complicated by the fact that there are two children, one his and one his enemy’s, and that he has no way to tell them apart – and to destroy that enemy.
The travelling party includes Philippa Somerville, who is set on looking after the child; Archie Abernathy; Jerrott Blyth, from the company formed at St, Mary’s; the maker of the spinet and the young woman who is his apprentice. Along the way the party will fracture, shining a different light on to familiar characters and illuminating new ones.
I knew that many readers love Philippa Somerville, and in this book I thought that she came into her own as a principled and strong-willed young woman, and I found that I loved her too. Jerrott Blyth became a complex character with a life and a story of his own, moving forward from the shadows in the last book. I came to love Archie Abernathy, and I wished I could spend more time with him and learn more of his back-story. I can’t help feeling there are volumes and volumes of history and biography that I would so loved to read that Dorothy Dunnett distilled to create her books.
There are some exceptional women in this series of books, and the young woman apprentice is as exceptional as any of them. I can’t say that I liked her, but I was intrigued by her and it was clear that she was significant for the thread that has been running throughout this series of books: the mystery surrounding the Crawford family and the possibility that a greater power than the enemy being sought is weaving an elaborate plot around Lymond.
I found a great deal to think about, I found a wealth of wonderful plot twists, some of which I saw coming but many of which I did not. I was pleased with some of the things I spotted, but I suspect that I am being cleverly managed by the author. When I read the first book in this series I wrote that it was lovely to be able to listen to someone so much cleverer than me, who was so articulate, who had so much to say about a subject that she loved, and that still holds true.
The evocation of places, of events, of cultures, continues to be vivid, deep and complex,
The thing that made this book distinctive for me was the use of perspective – most of the story is told from the perspective of Philippa Somerville or Jerrott Blyth. That illuminated their characters, and it also held Lymond at a distance so that much of his character remains in shadow.
I could see that he had matured since the earlier books, that he took responsibility for his companions in a way that he hadn’t often before, and he had no ready answer when he was asked if the object of his quest justified the price that he and others were paying. The price that he paid was highest of all, and the choice that he was forced to make in the grand set- piece of this book – a live game of chess – was utterly devastating.
The story went on a little too long for me after that, but I understood that there had to be a return journey, that pieces had to be put on place for the next book.
The consequences of what Lymond went through in this book – and of what he and others learned – have still to play out.
One side of the story seems to have played out in this book, but another side – the deeper story, I think, is coming to the fore.
As is another exceptional woman.
I’m not sure that I’m ready to be so close to the end of all of this, but I have to press on with the next book ….
6 thoughts on “Pawn in Frankincence by Dorothy Dunnett (1969)”
What a lovely, insightful post, Jane. This is a wonderful book, as all of Dunnett’s are, but it certainly does leave you emotionally drained – the chess scene is unforgettable. The point you make about the use of perspective is one of the things I find most intriguing about the whole series. We rarely get to see anything from Lymond’s point of view so have to depend on the other characters’ observations of him, which may or may not be reliable. I understand the feeling of being desperate to continue while not wanting it all to be over, but I’m finding that re-reads are very rewarding too. 🙂
I agree with Helen, a lovely review, Jane! I find this the most challenging book in the series, though I love Philippa’s journey. And I so agree about Archie. If you didn’t know, Dorothy Dunnett was also a painter of portraits (and you can see that influence in the “Dolly” books), and she did a portrait of Archie – I believe there is an elephant in it as well.
Oh my! I feel like I’m missing out on something exceptional here. I must make time to read this series.
Every time you post on one of these, I wish I was reading the series with you!
I haven’t heard of this series and it sounds wonderful!
Sounds intriguing. I prefer books that end at the conclusion, with an adequate denouement. i it keeps extending the story to set up the next cliff hanger is set up to lure the reader to keep reading, i am likely to simply stop reading.
Comments are closed.